The Best Fire Starters for a Fire Pit
A starter is not there to save you a match. It is there to hold a flame long enough to dry and light kindling, which is the step where most fires fail. Here is what separates them.
DisclosureWe earn a commission when you buy through the links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Prices come from Amazon and change without notice. How this site is funded.
Buy wax-and-fiber cubes, and buy the box that publishes a count so you can work out the cost per fire. Waterproofing is the one claim worth paying for if your wood or your starters live outside. Skip lighter fluid entirely — it is the most dangerous thing anyone routinely does at a fire pit.
How we judged these
- Ranked on published count first, because cost per fire is the only figure that matters and you cannot work it out without a count.
- Then on water resistance, which is the one claim that changes whether the product still works after a winter in a shed.
- Then on stated burn time — a spec almost nobody in this category publishes, which is itself worth knowing.
- Every count, claim and rated use is quoted from the current retail listing and cited on that product's own spec sheet. Where a listing publishes nothing, the row says so.
- What we did not do: light any of these, time a burn, or test a waterproof claim.
We have not burned any of these units, and we do not claim to have. The full method, including what it cannot tell you.
| # | Product | Best for | Key spec | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  Boulder's Fireside Legacy Fire Starter Cubes, 160 pcsThe only starter here whose listing claims all three of natural, odorless and waterproof, at 160 pieces. Waterproof is the spec that matters if your wood pile lives outside, because a starter that has absorbed moisture is just an expensive wood chip. | Damp wood and damp weather | Natural, odorless, waterproof | $23.99 · View on Amazon |
| 2 |  Rutland Natural Firestarter CubesRutland has sold hearth products for decades and the listing states the cubes are natural and work across campfire, fire pit, wood stove, chimney and charcoal. That breadth is the argument: one box covers the grill and the pit rather than two. | The one to buy if you buy once | Natural firestarter | $24.99 · View on Amazon |
| 3 |  Melt Candle Company Fire Starter, 160 Cubes160 cubes rated for charcoal grill, campfire and fireplace. The listing says less than the Boulder's box does, so it wins on nothing in particular — but it is a wax-and-fiber cube from a candle maker, which is exactly what this product is meant to be. | A straight bulk buy | Not stated on the listing | $21.24 · View on Amazon |
| 4 |  HGD Natural Fire Starters, 64 Mini SquaresSixty-four mini squares rather than 160 full ones. The right size of first purchase: enough to learn whether you need one square or two under your kindling, without a five-year supply sitting in the garage. | Trying starters without committing | Natural | $8.99 · View on Amazon |
| 5 |  E500 Waterproof Firestarter SticksSticks rather than cubes, and waterproof per the listing. A stick packs into a bag better than a crumbling cube and can be split lengthways for a small fire, which is why this is the one to keep with the camping gear. | A camping bag or a glovebox | Waterproof firestarter | $6.99 · View on Amazon |
Prices are pulled live from Amazon. Where no live price is showing, the button reads “check price” rather than a number we cannot stand behind.
Boulder's Fireside Legacy Fire Starter Cubes, 160 pcs
Boulder's Fireside LegacyThe only starter here whose listing claims all three of natural, odorless and waterproof, at 160 pieces. Waterproof is the spec that matters if your wood pile lives outside, because a starter that has absorbed moisture is just an expensive wood chip.
The only starter here whose listing claims all three of natural, odorless and waterproof, at 160 pieces. Waterproof is the spec that matters if your wood pile lives outside, because a starter that has absorbed moisture is just an expensive wood chip.
- 160 pieces is enough for a season of weekend fires at one or two cubes each
- Waterproof is published, which is the difference between working and not in a damp shed
- Odorless matters more than it sounds when you are cooking over the same fire
- No burn time published, so you cannot tell whether one cube or three lights a log
- Bulk packs go stale in storage if the box is opened and left in the weather
- A newer brand name with less trading history behind it than Rutland
Anyone storing wood outdoors, or lighting fires in a damp climate.
You light two fires a year — 160 cubes will outlive your interest in them.
We have not burned this unit. These are the things a specification sheet cannot answer, listed rather than glossed over.
- Burn minutes per cube
- Exact composition behind “natural”
#ad how we are funded · price as of October 18, 2026
Rutland Natural Firestarter Cubes
RutlandRutland has sold hearth products for decades and the listing states the cubes are natural and work across campfire, fire pit, wood stove, chimney and charcoal. That breadth is the argument: one box covers the grill and the pit rather than two.
Rutland has sold hearth products for decades and the listing states the cubes are natural and work across campfire, fire pit, wood stove, chimney and charcoal. That breadth is the argument: one box covers the grill and the pit rather than two.
- One product for the fire pit, the wood stove and the charcoal grill
- A hearth brand with a long trading history rather than a three-month-old storefront
- Cubes light from a match without lighter fluid or kindling gymnastics
- Neither the count nor the burn time is published, so cost per fire cannot be worked out
- More expensive than the bulk 160-piece boxes on a per-fire basis, most likely
- Not waterproof according to the listing, unlike the Boulder's and E500 options
The buyer who wants one reliable box in the garage and no further thought.
You want a published count and burn time to compare — buy the bulk packs instead.
We have not burned this unit. These are the things a specification sheet cannot answer, listed rather than glossed over.
- Pieces per box
- Minutes of burn per cube
#ad how we are funded · price as of October 18, 2026
Melt Candle Company Fire Starter, 160 Cubes
Melt Candle Company160 cubes rated for charcoal grill, campfire and fireplace. The listing says less than the Boulder's box does, so it wins on nothing in particular — but it is a wax-and-fiber cube from a candle maker, which is exactly what this product is meant to be.
160 cubes rated for charcoal grill, campfire and fireplace. The listing says less than the Boulder's box does, so it wins on nothing in particular — but it is a wax-and-fiber cube from a candle maker, which is exactly what this product is meant to be.
- Same 160-piece count as the Boulder's box, so the per-fire cost is comparable
- Made by a candle company, which is the right manufacturing background for a wax cube
- Covers the grill as well as the pit
- Publishes less than the competing 160-piece box at a similar price
- No waterproof claim, so damp storage is a real risk
- No burn time, again making cost per fire guesswork
Buyers who just want a large box of cubes and are not comparing spec sheets.
You are choosing on published facts — the Boulder's listing simply says more.
We have not burned this unit. These are the things a specification sheet cannot answer, listed rather than glossed over.
- Composition
- Water resistance
- Burn minutes
#ad how we are funded · price as of October 18, 2026
HGD Natural Fire Starters, 64 Mini Squares
HGDSixty-four mini squares rather than 160 full ones. The right size of first purchase: enough to learn whether you need one square or two under your kindling, without a five-year supply sitting in the garage.
Sixty-four mini squares rather than 160 full ones. The right size of first purchase: enough to learn whether you need one square or two under your kindling, without a five-year supply sitting in the garage.
- A sensible trial quantity at the lowest outlay of the cube options here
- Mini squares let you use half as much on kindling that is already dry
- Broad rated use, including indoor stoves
- Mini means you will use two or three on damp wood, eroding the price advantage
- No waterproofing claim
- 64 pieces goes quickly if you burn weekly
First-time buyers working out how many cubes their wood actually needs.
You already know you burn weekly — buy 160 and stop re-ordering.
We have not burned this unit. These are the things a specification sheet cannot answer, listed rather than glossed over.
- Cube dimensions
- Burn minutes per square
#ad how we are funded · price as of October 18, 2026
E500 Waterproof Firestarter Sticks
E500Sticks rather than cubes, and waterproof per the listing. A stick packs into a bag better than a crumbling cube and can be split lengthways for a small fire, which is why this is the one to keep with the camping gear.
Sticks rather than cubes, and waterproof per the listing. A stick packs into a bag better than a crumbling cube and can be split lengthways for a small fire, which is why this is the one to keep with the camping gear.
- Waterproof and stick-shaped, which is the format that survives a backpack
- Splittable, so one stick can serve a small fire rather than being all-or-nothing
- The cheapest entry here by list price
- The listing publishes almost nothing — no count, no burn time, no composition
- A new brand with little trading history
- Sticks need a knife to split, which cubes do not
Campers and anyone who wants a starter that survives being carried around.
You light fires at home from a dry shed. A cube is easier and better documented.
We have not burned this unit. These are the things a specification sheet cannot answer, listed rather than glossed over.
- Pieces per pack
- Burn minutes
- What the sticks are made from
#ad how we are funded · price as of October 18, 2026
What a starter is actually for
A match produces a flame for a couple of seconds. Kindling needs considerably longer than that — it has to be heated until it gives off flammable gas, and only then does it catch. The whole function of a fire starter is to bridge that gap: to keep a small, steady flame under the kindling for several minutes while the wood gets hot enough to take over.
That is why newspaper is a poor starter despite being free. It flares, burns out in under a minute, and leaves ash that blocks the airflow you need. A wax cube does the opposite: a low flame, for minutes, in one place.
Cost per fire, not cost per box
Two of the boxes here hold 160 pieces and one holds 64. That is the number that decides what a fire actually costs you, and it is why we rank on published count before anything else. A box that does not tell you how many pieces are inside cannot be compared to one that does, however established the brand is.
The other half of the equation is how many cubes a fire takes, and that depends almost entirely on your wood. Properly seasoned or kiln-dried wood lights from one cube. Wood that has been under a tarp through a wet spring may take three, which turns a season's supply into a third of one. If you are going through cubes faster than you expected, the honest fix is in the best wood to burn, not in a different starter.
| Product | Count | Waterproof | Burn time |
|---|---|---|---|
| Boulder's Fireside Legacy | 160 pcs | Stated | Not stated |
| Rutland | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated |
| Melt Candle Company | 160 cubes | Not stated | Not stated |
| HGD | 64 mini squares | Not stated | Not stated |
| E500 | Not stated | Stated | Not stated |
Not one listing in this category publishes a burn time. That is a remarkable gap in a product whose entire job is to burn for a known number of minutes.
Waterproof is the claim that matters
Wax is not especially hygroscopic, but the fiber it is bound to is. A cube that has spent a winter in a damp shed lights reluctantly and burns shorter than it should, and because it still lights you never quite diagnose it — you conclude the wood is bad and put another log on.
Two of the five here publish a water-resistance claim. If your starters live in the garage in a sealed box, that is worth nothing to you. If they live in the same crate as the wood, beside the pit, it is the difference between a product that works in March and one that does not.
Cubes or sticks
Cubes are the default and the easier format: drop one or two under the kindling, light the corner, walk away. Sticks are the better traveling format — they survive being carried, they can be split lengthways when you only need half, and they do not crumble into wax dust at the bottom of a bag.
For a pit in a backyard, buy cubes. For a pit that goes camping, or a set of tools that lives in a car, buy sticks. That is genuinely the whole decision, and it is the reason a stick product ranks last here on published facts while still being the right answer for one specific buyer.
How to use one properly
- 1Build the lay first. The cube goes in last, underneath, not on top of a pile you then rearrange.
- 2Put the cube where air can reach it from below. A cube sitting flat on a bed of ash is starved from one side.
- 3Use kindling that is genuinely thin — thumb-width splits, not offcuts. The cube's job is to light kindling, and kindling's job is to light the log.
- 4Light the corner of the cube, not the middle. It will take on its own.
- 5Leave it alone for three or four minutes. Poking a new fire is how people put it out, which is a different job from the one the poker is for later on.
If you want the structures that make this reliable, and the one lay that produces markedly less smoke than the others, that is all in how to start a fire in a fire pit. This page is only about what you put underneath it.
What we would skip
- Lighter fluid or gasoline
Petrol vapor pools in a cold bowl and lights as a whole volume rather than a surface. This is the single most common way people get hurt at a fire pit, and it never appears on a list of things you need.
- Starters as a substitute for dry wood
A cube burns for a few minutes. Wet wood needs far longer than that to dry out and catch. If the fire keeps dying after the starter goes out, the problem is the wood, not the starter.
- Bulk boxes left open in a damp shed
Only two listings here claim any water resistance. A wax cube that has been sitting in humidity all winter lights unevenly and burns short, which is exactly when you blame the wood instead.